Instance 90_09 using the Global Sequencing Constraint
NODES
TIME
avg
min
avg
min
s_l_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.49 1.46
r_e_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.57 1.48
pq_e_m_c_gs 192.00 190.00 1.47 1.46
R_s_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.37 1.35
L_e_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.37 1.37
R_l_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.38 1.34
L_l_m_o_gs 325.00 325.00 3.18 3.16
d_s_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.41 1.38
d_l_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.55 1.53
d_e_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.55 1.53
s_l_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.36 1.32
s_l_m_o_gs 325.00 325.00 4.03 3.96
S_l_l_o_gs 325.00 325.00 4.37 4.34
l_l_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.48 1.45
l_l_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.36 1.32
s_s_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.53 1.49
L_s_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.58 1.52
r_s_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.57 1.52
R_e_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.38 1.36
R_l_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.51 1.49
S_e_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.33 1.31
S_l_m_o_gs 325.00 325.00 4.03 3.98
r_l_l_o_gs 325.00 325.00 4.05 4.03
l_e_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.36 1.33
pq_s_m_c_gs 192.00 190.00 1.47 1.45
pq_l_m_c_gs 192.00 190.00 1.49 1.46
l_l_m_o_gs 325.00 325.00 3.16 3.14
S_e_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.53 1.48
d_l_m_o_gs 323.00 323.00 3.44 3.42
s_l_l_o_gs 325.00 325.00 4.37 4.33
mo_s_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.43 1.42
S_s_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.53 1.49
S_s_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.34 1.34
pq_s_l_c_gs 193.60 192.00 1.52 1.51
r_l_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.37 1.33
s_e_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.34 1.32
R_e_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.57 1.48
L_s_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.36 1.34
pq_l_m_o_gs 285.00 285.00 3.46 3.44
L_e_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.56 1.47
d_s_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.62 1.52
d_e_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.41 1.37
r_e_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.37 1.35
R_l_l_o_gs 325.00 325.00 4.11 4.07
R_l_m_o_gs 325.00 325.00 3.45 3.44
d_l_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.40 1.36
pq_l_l_o_gs 293.00 293.00 3.48 3.46
L_l_l_o_gs 325.00 325.00 3.48 3.47
s_s_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.34 1.34
s_e_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.52 1.47
S_l_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.50 1.47
d_l_l_o_gs 323.00 323.00 3.77 3.70
r_l_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.50 1.48
l_s_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.35 1.34
l_s_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.56 1.51
l_e_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.54 1.45
mo_s_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.58 1.55
pq_l_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.54 1.51
S_l_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.36 1.33
pq_e_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.53 1.50
r_l_m_o_gs 325.00 325.00 3.41 3.39
L_l_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.50 1.48
L_l_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.36 1.33
r_s_m_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.37 1.34
l_l_l_o_gs 325.00 325.00 3.42 3.40
R_s_l_c_gs 194.00 194.00 1.62 1.58

Best configurations

['L_e_l_c_gs', 'L_e_m_c_gs', 'L_l_l_c_gs', 'L_l_l_o_gs', 'L_l_m_c_gs', 'L_l_m_o_gs', 'L_s_l_c_gs', 'L_s_m_c_gs', 'R_e_l_c_gs', 'R_e_m_c_gs', 'R_l_l_c_gs', 'R_l_l_o_gs', 'R_l_m_c_gs', 'R_l_m_o_gs', 'R_s_l_c_gs', 'R_s_m_c_gs', 'S_e_l_c_gs', 'S_e_m_c_gs', 'S_l_l_c_gs', 'S_l_l_o_gs', 'S_l_m_c_gs', 'S_l_m_o_gs', 'S_s_l_c_gs', 'S_s_m_c_gs', 'd_e_l_c_gs', 'd_e_m_c_gs', 'd_l_l_c_gs', 'd_l_l_o_gs', 'd_l_m_c_gs', 'd_l_m_o_gs', 'd_s_l_c_gs', 'd_s_m_c_gs', 'l_e_l_c_gs', 'l_e_m_c_gs', 'l_l_l_c_gs', 'l_l_l_o_gs', 'l_l_m_c_gs', 'l_l_m_o_gs', 'l_s_l_c_gs', 'l_s_m_c_gs', 'mo_s_l_c_gs', 'mo_s_m_c_gs', 'pq_e_l_c_gs', 'pq_e_m_c_gs', 'pq_l_l_c_gs', 'pq_l_l_o_gs', 'pq_l_m_c_gs', 'pq_l_m_o_gs', 'pq_s_l_c_gs', 'pq_s_m_c_gs', 'r_e_l_c_gs', 'r_e_m_c_gs', 'r_l_l_c_gs', 'r_l_l_o_gs', 'r_l_m_c_gs', 'r_l_m_o_gs', 'r_s_l_c_gs', 'r_s_m_c_gs', 's_e_l_c_gs', 's_e_m_c_gs', 's_l_l_c_gs', 's_l_l_o_gs', 's_l_m_c_gs', 's_l_m_o_gs', 's_s_l_c_gs', 's_s_m_c_gs']

Description

Each table represents some statics related to given configuration. A configuration is denoted by A_B_C_D_E where :
  1. A is the selection criteria. We denote by
    • mo : Max option
    • pq : The capacity q\p
    • d : The residual demand
    • l : The load
    • s : The slack
    • r : The usage rate
  2. B is the aggregation function. We denote by
    • l : Lexicographic order
    • s : Sum of the elements
    • e : Euclidean norm
  3. C is the exploration criteria. We denote by
    • l : Lexicographic exploration
    • m : Middle towars sides
  4. D is the Branching parameter. We denote by
    • o : Option
    • c : Class
  5. E is the filtering model. We denote by
    • n : The default model using sum constraints
    • am : The model using the AtMostSeqCard Constraint
    • gs : The model using the Global Sequencing Constraint (GSC)
    • gsam : The model combining AtMostSeqCard+GSC
    • f : The model using the new filtering algorithm